Posts Tagged ‘Climate Change’

Guy the Friday Mash Superfly was perched on a wall in the prime minister’s office when Julia and Wayne met with Bob, Rob and Tony, the three independents. Here is his exclusive report on this historic event.
‘Gentlemen’ said Julia ‘I’m sure you understand that the future of this great nation depends on us forming a stable coalition government and preventing Mr Rabbit and his mob from becoming a plague in rural Australia’
‘What concessions are you prepared to offer us?’ asked Rob
‘And how about doing a nude centrefold in our local paper?’ asked Bob
‘I beg your pardon’ said Julia
‘Only joking’ said Bob
‘But we couldn’t consider’ said Tony ‘going into a coalition with any party which wants to apply an ETS to farmers’
‘Well’ said Julia ‘of course we will be prepared to discuss that issue in good faith with you but Penny Wong assures me…’
‘Penny Wong’ exclaimed Bob ‘she’s not still around is she? I thought she got lost in Copenhagen’
‘Not just Penny’ said Julia ‘but also Peter Garrett will sit down with you to consider…’
‘Oh shit’ said Bob ‘don’t tell me Peter Garrett’s still stuffing things up. If he comes up to my electorate they’ll go batts. And you’re not considering an alliance with the Greens are you?’
‘As a matter of fact’ said Julia ‘Bob Brown and I have been having some mutually encouraging discussions’
‘Well if you want us’ said Bob ‘you can forget them. I’d get on better with red politburo members from China than green senators from Tasmania. What’s Kevin up to?’
‘Following his quite inspirational contribution to our election campaign’ said Julia ‘Kevin is preparing himself to take on a senior role in my cabinet’
‘You have to be joking’ said Bob ‘you’re not seriously considering having that wanker in your cabinet are you? He couldn’t organise a leak in a toilet. And who was the braindead buffoon who came up with that mining tax?’
‘Well actually’ said Wayne ‘I’m proud to tell you that Ken Henry and I are responsible for that landmark economic reform’
‘Are you mad?’ asked Bob ‘The only decent jobs in my electorate are in mining. What are the miners supposed to do instead, build thousands of bloody windmills?’
‘And we don’t think your population policy’s sustainable’ said Tony ‘We need all the asylum seekers we can get to achieve sustainable regional development. It’s no good sending them to Sydney. If that state Labor government stays in much longer it will be much more humane to send them all back to Afghanistan’
‘I get so tired flying backwards and forwards to Canberra’ said Bob ‘what about transferring federal parliament to Charters Towers?’
‘I’ll consider it’ said Julia ‘if it’s the only way I can remain as prime minister. Thank you gentlemen for a most encouraging meeting. There are so many points of agreement we can take forward into our discussions next week. And are there any final comments you’d like to make?’
‘Yes’ said Bob ‘about the allocation of ministries. Rob would like Regional Development, Tony would like non-Sustainable Population and Immigration and I’ll take Climate Change so I can stuff that ETS for once and for all’
‘Anything else?’ asked Julia
‘Yes’ said Bob ‘that broadband network’s a great idea. Do I need a computer to connect with it?’
Tags: Bob Brown, Bob Katter humour, Climate Change, ETS, Guy the Fly, home insulation scheme, Julia Gillard humour, Ken Henry satire, Kevin Rudd satire, mining tax, NBN, Penny Wong satire, Peter Garrett satire, Rob Oakeshott humour, the Greens, Tony Abbott satire, Tony Windsor humour, Wayne Swan satire
Posted in Fly on the Wall | No Comments »

The Dick Head Interview with Julia Gillard
Politicians go out of their way as far as possible to avoid being interviewed by our Canberra correspondent Dick Head.
Julia had the bad luck to accidentally sit next to him at a Canberra coffee shop.
Here is a transcript of his off the record interview made available exclusively and in strictest confidence to Mashmates.
‘Now Julia’ said Dick ‘you’ve really stuffed-up on climate change. Who was the loony who came up with the Citizens Assembly thing?’
‘It’s a brilliant concept I came up with’ said Julia ‘to do something positive about doing sod-all. If I’d reintroduced the ETS Kevin and Al Gore would be doing victory laps all round the country. But I’ll stack the Citizens Assembly with greenies, listen carefully to their conclusions and then do whatever it takes to stay ahead in the opinion polls.
‘I can’t believe’ said Dick ‘you are dumb-assed enough to try and build another asylum seeker processing centre in East Timor when we already have one in Nauru’
‘I see your point’ said Julia ‘but John Howard built that one and I can’t be seen to be doing anything as irresponsible as following his policies. I’d consider Nauru if I was moving backwards and hadn’t got any money to waste on another centre’
‘How on earth’ asked Dick ‘are you going to manage the country’s economy without Lindsay Tanner? I mean you haven’t got a clue about it and by 2013 Wayne won’t know whether he’s surplus, topless or shitless’
‘Well’ said Julia ‘I’ll probably ask Mark Arbib and Bill Shorten to take a stab at it behind Wayne’s back’
‘And you’re not much chop at foreign affairs are you?’ said Dick ‘I mean fancy phoning Ramos Horta about that processing centre in East Timor’
‘That was an extremely clever ploy’ said Julia ‘If I’d phoned Xanana Gusmao he’d have pissed himself laughing’
‘And what about the miners?’ asked Dick ‘You’ve got a right mess on your hands. You did a deal with the big three, pissed off all the rest and now they’re restarting their vitriolic ad campaign’
‘Well Dick’ said Julia ‘I wouldn’t put it exactly like that. I’m already raising 10.5 billion for the good of everyone in Australia except the mining industry. And if Wayne hadn’t stuffed up the sums he’d already stuffed up it could have been 24 billion. And when they restart their campaign it will only confirm to people that they should be bled to the point where they can’t afford anti-government advertising campaigns’
‘Now’ said Dick ‘moving forward what are you going to do about Kevin?’
‘Christ knows’ said Julia ‘I’m praying that he gets a full-time job at the United Nations. Is he doesn’t I’ll offer to pay them to take him on. If that fails I’ll have to grit my teeth, make him foreign minister and see if BP can supply the right plug to stop him leaking.
‘And now’ said Dick ‘what is your main priority moving forward?’
‘To get you to stop using that stupid ‘moving forward’ line’ said Julia ‘You don’t know how irritating it is’
Tags: Al Gore humor, asylum seekers, Bill Shorten humour, BP oil leak, Citizens Assembly, Climate Change, Dick Head, ETS, John Howard satire, Julia Gillard humour, Kevin Rudd satire, Lindsay Tanner jokes, Mark Arbib humour, mining tax, Ramos Horta humour, Roger Pugh, Wayne Swan satire, Xanana Gusmao satire
Posted in Canberra correspondent - Dick Head, Election Sanity | No Comments »
ETS banter continues triggering an assessment of citizens participation


or add this comic to your website, blog or forum:
Just copy and paste the code below.
Tags: Climate Change, Copenhagen Conference, ETS, Gay Niblett
Posted in Cartoon Library | No Comments »

The Dick Head Interview
with Tony Abbott
Dick Head, our Canberra correspondent is the man who gets answers. His irresponsible interviewing style has driven politicians mad for years.
The interview with Tony Abbott took place at a seedy bar in Manly. It was strictly off the record but Dick took the wholly irresponsible decision to make it available to Mashmates and their confidantes.
‘Thank you Tony’ said Dick ‘mine’s a double. Isn’t that climate change policy of yours a load of crap?’
‘Of course’ said Tony ‘it’s carefully designed to get the shit off the stage. But when the public find out that global warming is about as real as Wayne’s budget surplus I’ll be a hero for saving them from a massive tax’
‘But what if global warming turns out to be the greatest moral challenge of our generation?’ asked Dick
‘I’ll take holy orders’ said Tony ‘and become a Greens senator from Tasmania’
‘Why don’t you stop farting around on Work Choices?’ demanded Dick ‘you’re obviously going to re-introduce it if you’re elected’
‘That’s true’ said Tony ‘but the only way I can re-introduce Work Choices is by being elected and to achieve that I’ve got to promise not to re-introduce it’
‘So your promise not to re-introduce Work Choices means stuff-all’ said Dick
‘It means’ said Tony ‘that I will honour that promise right up to the time I’m elected. You can’t expect election promises to apply after an election’
‘That’s bullshit’ said Dick ‘that means punters shouldn’t believe any promise you make during the election campaign’
‘Of course they should’ said Tony ‘I’ve got a perfect record of never reneging on an election promise before an election. But people must understand that while election promises are an invaluable guide on how they should vote there’s no way they will be relevant when we get into office and understand what’s really needed’
‘Isn’t it your shout?’ asked Dick ‘yes thanks I’ll have another double. So what about your pissant promise to dump the new mining tax?’
‘Cast iron guarantee’ said Tony ‘The tax won’t be up and running when I become prime minister so that’s one promise I’m bound to keep’
‘Aren’t your front-bench a load of deadbeats?’ asked Dick
‘Pretty much’ said Tony ‘Nobody’s heard of Warren Truss, Julie says more stupid things than I do, Barnaby Joyce is so bitchy he’ll soon become Joyce Barnaby, Christopher Pyne needles everybody but Joe Hockey could make two of Wayne Swan’
‘Aren’t you worried that the public see you as a larrikin loose cannon?’ asked Dick
‘No’ said Tony ‘because I never actually became a priest. They see me as a straight-shooter’
‘Do you think you’ll score a bull’s eye on Julia?’ asked Dick
‘No’ said Tony ‘that’s an impossibility when you’re shooting at a horse’s ass. Oh sorry I was going to get you a double’
‘Well in the spirit of the election campaign’ said Dick ‘the truth is I asked for a treble’
Tags: Barnaby Joyce humour, Christopher Pyne, Climate Change, Dick Head, ETS, Joe Hockey humour, Julia Gillard humour, Julie Bishop, mining tax, Tony Abbott satire, Warren Truss, Wayne Swan satire, Work Choices
Posted in Canberra correspondent - Dick Head, Election Sanity | 2 Comments »
There’s a hint of something sinister in the air in Canberra. Politicians have been doing even weirder things than usual.
First the ghostly Godwin Grech spooked Malcolm, then Kevin contracted compulsive backflip disorder, Tony has let Kerry O’Brien make an honest dishonest man of him and now Wayne is trying to convert the mining industry into an extension of the Tax Department.
Friday Mash’s confidential investigative sources in Canberra believe they’re on to something. They are possibly uncovering evidence that senior female federal ministers have formed a witches’ coven and are hatching sinister plots. Could it be that Julia Gillard, Nicola Roxon and Penny Wong have decided to stir the pot and weave their malicious magic?

Penny obviously blames Tony for her post fatal depression over the ETS. Nicola must be sick and tired of trailing Kevin round hospitals like a mid-wife in case he gave birth to something or had to abort another promise. All three are Tonyphobic because he’s against abortions and they believe Kevin should be able to have one whenever he wants.
But above all Kevin’s sent them stir crazy because they all thought he was full of promise and he’s turned out to be merely full of himself. Wayne’s now taking credit for everything and has to be stopped before Visa and American Express cancel his cards.
Rumour hath it that wicked spells abound.
Double, double, toil and trouble
Fire burn and cauldron bubble
Government sources are still not worried. They have been saying for months that Kevin needs a spell. But if he’s gone off the boil the cauldron certainly hasn’t.
When shall we three meet again
In thunder, lightning or in rain
These wild chants echoing around Canberra are starting to get people worried. It has been confirmed that there have been no current productions of Macbeth in the city. Someone suggested they might be coming from a group concerned about climate change.
Round about the cauldron go
In the poisoned entrails throw
There is no clear indication of the nature of these poisoned entrails but a watch is being kept at hospitals to check whether John Howard has his appendix or his gall bladder removed.
Eye of newt and toe of frog
Wool of bat and tongue of dog
Throwing in batts wool is really going to add insulation fuel to the fire.
Canberra is rife with rumours. Is Julie Bishop under a spell or does she always look like that? Will Bronwyn emerge in the terrifying image of Lady Macbeth and act as though she’s married to Kevin?
Are Julia, Nicola and Penny even now shrieking the hideous chants and casting the diabolical spells which will render Kevin ready for a tap on the shoulder from Julia’s broomstick?
Fair is foul and foul is fair
Hover through the fog and filthy air
Lead on MacDuff. Someone’s got to find a way through all those carbon emissions.
Tags: American Express, ATO, Bronwyn Bishop, Carbon Emissions, Climate Change, ETS, Godwin Grech, home insulation scheme, hospitals, John Howard, Julia Gillard, Julie Bishop, Kerry O’Brien, Kevin Rudd, Lady Macbeth, MacDuff, Malcolm Turnbull, mining tax, Nicola Roxon, Penny Wong, Roger Pugh, super profits tax, Tony Abbott, Visa, Wayne Swan
Posted in Weekly Mash | 2 Comments »
For some time Friday Mash has perceived that politicians have a serious communication problem. Political rhetoric is becoming increasingly detached from reality.
Some argue it is unreasonable to expect politicians to tell the truth when it could cost them votes or their job. Others are concerned that politicians could lose all credibility if they become totally disconnected from the bleedin’ obvious.
For example Julia sees the building of an education revolution while the public sees revoltingly overpriced and undersized school buildings.
NoSpin Doctors is yet another political public service from Friday Mash. We have assembled a team with world class expertise in derevolutionising spin and getting to the truth of the matter. Their first assignment is to help you understand what Kevin might have said about the ETS if he wasn’t a prime political spinner.
Here is their NoSpin version.
“Climate change was very effective in helping me win the 07 election and also in identifying me as a world-class statesman and future Secretary General of the United Nations.
I called climate change ‘The greatest moral challenge of our generation’ because that was the best slogan the spin doctors could come up with and it made me sound really committed.
There’s no doubt that Malcolm Turnbull is an all-time bombastic pompous twit but it was great to have him onside in the ETS debate.
I became convinced that the ETS was an absolute no-brainer because it raised tons of taxes, needed a whole new level of bureaucracy and reduced the Coalition to a heap of carbon-emiting ashes.
Everything was proceeding brilliantly until that prime pain in the arse Tony Abbott rolled Malcolm and the ETS went down the tubes together with my chances of being the star of the Copenhagen Conference.
I acknowledge that Penny and I exaggerated the consequences of not passing the ETS legislation through the Parliament before Copenhagen. I’m sure people understood that bushfires, droughts and raging seas would not actually engulf Australia before Christmas but I was apprehensive that if I went to Copenhagen without an ETS no-one would take any notice of me. At least I got that right.
In retrospect I have to admit that Tony was right about not rushing ahead with the ETS before Copenhagen and of course the Coalition was quite right to throw it out in the Senate.
If it had passed Australia would be lumbered with a massive tax on everything and be hopelessly uncompetitive in world markets. I only wish I’d heeded Tony’s advice sooner.
My decision to abandon the ETS and a few other difficult projects has caused my poll numbers to drop. But I do not shrink from the tough decisions needed to axe projects resulting from my stupid decisions in the first place.
Yes it’s true the ETS is a massive tax on everything and Penny and I were less than frank about its true impacts, but I think it’s a bit rich that from Beijing to London and right across Australia I am now being subjected to an outbreak of global cooling.”
Tags: BER, Building the Education Revolution, Climate Change, Climate Change Conference, Copenhagen, Copenhagen Conference, ETS, global cooling, global warming, greatest moral challenge of our generation, Julia Gillard, Kevin 07, Kevin Rudd, Malcolm Turnbull, Penny Wong, Political rhetoric, Roger Pugh, Tony Abbott, United Nations
Posted in Weekly Mash | 1 Comment »

UK Report by Tori Banger
Lots of Ashes but Nothing Rising from Them
The cloud of volcanic ash hovering over the UK is seen by the faithful as a merciful intervention by the Almighty to draw a veil over the election.
The Liberal Democrat surge since the leaders debate has increased the likelihood of the UK election becoming every bit as shambolic as the Tasmanian election even without the Hare-brained-Clark electoral system.
The debate once again confirmed that the concept is the most boring, irrelevant and frustrating television offering since climate change documentaries.
If it turns out to be the catalyst for the Liberal Democrats getting even a sniff of government, history will rate it a disaster in the same league as Chamberlain in Munich.
The sort of change the Liberal Democrats would bring to governing the UK would reduce it to the status of a French Second Eleven.
The debate confirmed that Clegg is an Alice in Wonderland, Cameron is a Tory toff and Brown is suffering from selective amnesia which renders him completely unable to recall any of the downright idiotic, immoral or boneheaded things he has done as prime minister. And he has no recollection of anyone called Tonty Blair.
Vulcanologists believe most of the ash engulfing the UK does not come from Iceland but rather from Gordon’s volcanic tantrums.
Tori Banger is having second thoughts about an affair with David Cameron
Tags: Chamberlain, Climate Change, David Cameron, Gordon Brown, Liberal Democrat, Munich, Nick Clegg, Tasmanian Election, Tony Blair, Tori Banger, UK election, volcanic ash
Posted in Election Sanity, UK correspondent - Tori Banger | 6 Comments »
There has long been a suspicion that Malcolm’s surname had something to do with him being born in a manger.
Over the years, however, his claims as the ultimate Saviour have been undermined by an excess of epiphanies.
It is true that for most of his life he has been a leading Profit of the Neo-liberal faith. His reputation was confirmed by a number of miracles while Wizard of OzEmail and an ability to turn loaves and fishes into dollars.
His first deviation from the path of true righteousness was a dance with the devil of republicanism. This enraged King John who was the Neo-Liberal Monarch of the Land and he gave Malcolm a right royal kick up the referendum.
In his infinite mercy King John forgave Malcolm and encouraged his election to the Neo-Liberal broad church where he became Apostle of Water and Environment. Malcolm thought it would be a great opportunity to get amongst the greenbacks but instead it awakened within him a calling to Climate Change.
King Kevin, the leader of Climate Change in Australia, dethroned King John to become the new leader of the land while climate change disciple Malcolm became Leader of the Neo-Liberals.
At this time Godwin, a leading disciple of Malcolm’s, told him he had a vehicle for running over King Kevin and putting Malcolm in the driver’s seat. Alas it turned out to be merely a humble ute and Godwin was bearing false witness.
Some of the Neo-Liberals became really pissed with Malcolm over the parable of Utegate as well as his sermons in support of climate change and the religious ETS fanatic Penny.
The polls were indicating that his bright star had long since fallen from its position over Bethlehem and even Canberra.
A pall of smoke heavy with carbon emissions announced that the College of Cardinal Neo-Liberals had replaced Malcolm as Leader with the Mad Monk. Malcolm was quietly crucified and left to carry a Cross between Utegate and Climate Change of his own making.
And it came to pass that Barnaby, a leading Neo-Liberal apostle kept stuffing up his maths and the Mad Monk decided he had to be moved to a different diocese.
Deep within his humble resting place in the wastes of Westworth a flicker of Neo-Liberal life stirred within Malcolm. He was confident his maths were up to the job.
The Mad Monk, however, was not so sure. He believed Malcolm still followed the teachings of Climate Change. Before he got back into bed with Malcolm, he perceived he would need the sort of protection forbidden to him by another religion which keeps getting in his way.
And so it came to pass that there will be no Resurrection of Malcolm this Easter. It’s such a shame because his disciples had already booked a church to celebrate. And sadly they only needed a small church.
Malcolm is left with Easter Egg all over his face.
Tags: Barnaby Joyce, Bethlehem, Climate Change, Easter Egg, ETS, Godwin Grech, John Howard, Kevin Rudd, Mad Monk, Malcolm Turnbull, OzEmail, Penny Wong, Utegate
Posted in Politics, Weekly Mash | No Comments »
With the utmost respect to Kevin the greatest moral challenge of our time is not climate change but the propensity of politicians to raise taxes after they have promised faithfully not to.
They are absolutely shameless. George ‘read my lips’ Bush, Obama and Kevin have all transgressed and now Tony Abbott’s succumbed to temptation with some post-natal financial depression for business.
Politicians are noticeably reticent about tax increases during election campaigns. A promise to raise taxes would have roughly the same impact on the electorate as a promise to sell off their grandmothers into sexual slavery. Admittedly it might not resonate quite so badly with grandfathers.
Deep within the soul of every serving politician is the urge to do something really worthwhile for the community if only to get re-elected. But that requires a tax increase. If only politicians could come to grips with the incontrovertible truth that to do nothing apart from decreasing taxes is an absolute guarantee of staying in parliament long enough for pension paradise.
We already have income tax, surtax, goods and services tax, payroll tax, excise tax, pretax, corporate tax, capital gains tax, property tax and if you forget syntax you can end up with a long sentence.
Governments have even considered a tax on mistresses and lovers as a way of getting a bit on the side.
Which brings us to the Henry Tax Review. Why are Kevin and Wayne so reluctant to release it? It obviously contains conclusions and recommendations which favour taxpayers rather than the government.
For example there is the strong possibility it recognises that Australians are hopelessly over-taxed. Is it too much to hope that this will lead to a joyous federal election in which Kevin and Tony will try to outbid each other in promising tax cuts? Of course it is.
If the Review is to have any credibility whatsoever it must recommend that the Taxation Department becomes taxpayer friendly and appreciates the benefits which can flow from treating taxpayers humanely and gratefully.
It is surely not too much to expect an annual note of thanks from the Commissioner of Taxation for contributing so generously to his coffers. Special commendations and even discounts would not go amiss to taxpayers showing annual increases in contributions of twenty percent or more. Huge tax contributions over an extended period resulting from extraordinary toil or breathtaking brilliance from taxpayers should be recognised by a gong and an entry in the national accounts.
Back in the real world the Taxation Department assails us with horrendously complex documentation, nasty rude letters, innuendoes, demands and threats all of which offer no encouragement for taxpayers to become kindly and charitable towards them. As a result paying taxes promotes feelings similar to paying off blackmailers without police waiting at the drop-off point.
It is crucial that the Review recommends the withdrawal from state governments of any mandate to collect taxes. Politicians who are so indisciplined in spending taxpayer dollars shouldn’t be trusted to collect them. They could soon become as invasive as banks.
Above all the Review should recognise that Australian business would become much more profitable and tax-productive if they didn’t have to spend a considerable amount of time and money trying to decipher what on earth the Taxation Department is rabbiting on about and whether to relocate to Singapore or the Cayman Islands.
Governments can certainly tax you to death. Hopefully the Review recommends a tax-free after-life even for atheists.
Tags: ATO, Barack Obama, Cayman Islands, Climate Change, election campaigns, George Bush, George W Bush, Henry Tax Review, Kevin Rudd, KRudd, over-taxed, sexual slavery, Singapore, tax cuts, taxes, taxpayers, Tony Abbott, Wayne Swan
Posted in Weekly Mash | 1 Comment »

Street Wear
When he’s out promoting school hall building programmes Kevin wears a hard hat and he wears surgeon’s gear when he’s talking up his hospitals plan. What on earth will he wear to announce his policy for brothels?
Swearing Out Ceremony
There is a move in California to legislate against foul language. This is indicative that the State Treasury is only slightly more bankrupt than Californian English.
Blocker
The Labor Government wheeled out Stephen Conroy, Jennie Macklin, Penny Wong, Lindsay Tanner and Nicola Roxon for a media conference to moan about Tony Abbott blocking things. These are the architects of the disastrous Telstra plan, the laughable Aboriginal Housing Scheme, the ETS, the debt and deficit and the half-baked hospitals plan. Keep up the good work Tony.
Welcome to the Asylum
News that Yudhoyono is going to arrest people smugglers opens up the prospect of a real earner for the federal government. They could offer asylum seekers a cruise from Indonesia to Christmas Island on the Oceanic Viking for only five thousand dollars. This is less than the people smugglers charge, would earn unstinted praise from Amnesty International and could encourage Hyatt Hotels to build a decent pad on Christmas Island.
Travelling by Tube
It was disappointing to hear that Lara’s engagement ring had gone down the toilet especially, as now seems likely, she was wearing it at the time.
Unsuitable Treatment
It turned really frosty in Sydney when Kevin dropped in to talk to Kristina about hospitals. This was obviously another disastrous effect of climate change.
Non-Stop Motoring
Experts advise that you should only engage cruise control on Toyota vehicles if you’re low on petrol and on a long trip down a straight motorway.
Obama Drama
It looks like Obama wont be coming to Australia until his healthcare bill has been passed. He’s blaming Tony Abbott for blocking it in the Senate.
Tags: Aboriginal Housing Scheme, Amnesty International, asylum seekers, Barack Obama, Christmas Island, Climate Change, ETS, Health, healthcare, healthcare bill, hospitals, Hyatt Hotels, Indonesia, Jennie Macklin, Kevin Rudd, Kristina Keneally, KRudd, Labor Government, Labour Party, Lara Bingle, Lindsay Tanner, Nicola Roxon, Oceanic Viking, Penny Wong, people smugglers, Peter Costello, Stephen Conroy, Telstra, Tony Abbott, Toyota, Yudhoyono
Posted in Carbon Emissions | 1 Comment »